Skip to content

Course 20 · Lesson 5.4

Spiritual direction: the elder, the confessor, the pastor and the mentor

11 minute read

Lessons in this course

Course 20 outline

Module 1: Spiritual Formation and the Doctrines Behind Prayer

  1. What spiritual formation means in Scripture and tradition
  2. How the Trinity, the Incarnation and grace shape Christian prayer
  3. A map of the prayer traditions: Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant
  4. Ways and stages of growth: purgation, illumination and union, and their critics

Module 2: The Desert and Early Monasticism

  1. Anthony, Athanasius and the beginning of the desert movement
  2. The sayings of the Desert Fathers and Mothers: how to read them
  3. John Cassian and the eight thoughts that trouble the mind
  4. From the hermit to the community: Pachomius, Basil and Benedict

Module 3: Praying with Scripture and with the Church

  1. Lectio divina: its history and the four movements
  2. The Psalms as the prayer of the church
  3. The Divine Office and the Liturgy of the Hours: hours, texts and structure
  4. Using the daily office alone, and the Protestant daily prayer tradition

Module 4: Hesychasm and the Jesus Prayer

  1. Stillness and the prayer of the heart in the early Eastern church
  2. The Jesus Prayer: its words, its sources and its history
  3. Gregory Palamas and the fourteenth century controversy over light and energies
  4. Practice and cautions: the role of a guide and the warnings of the tradition

Module 5: Fasting, Discernment and Spiritual Direction

  1. Fasting in Scripture and in the three traditions
  2. Asceticism: its purpose, its dangers and its abuses
  3. The discernment of spirits from Antony and Cassian to Ignatius of Loyola
  4. Spiritual direction: the elder, the confessor, the pastor and the mentor

Module 6: Contemplation and Action

  1. Mary and Martha: how the church has read the two lives
  2. Prayer that issues in service: Benedict, Brother Lawrence and the Reformers on vocation
  3. When practice goes wrong: pride, quietism and spiritual experience without doctrine

Module 7: Building a Rule of Life

  1. What a rule of life is, and what the word rule meant for Benedict
  2. Choosing practices: Scripture, prayer, fasting, rest and service
  3. Dryness, failure and starting again
  4. Reviewing and adjusting a rule over time

All courses

Program / Course 20: Spiritual Theology / Lesson 5.4

What you will learn

  • Define spiritual direction and distinguish it from confession, counseling and teaching.
  • Describe the roles of the elder, confessor, pastor and mentor in the three traditions.
  • Explain why nearly every tradition values guidance from another person.
  • Name the qualities of a trustworthy guide and the signs of misuse.

The big idea

Spiritual direction is guidance in prayer and the Christian life from another person who is experienced and trusted. The practice goes back to the desert, where monks opened their thoughts to elders, and it appears in every major tradition under different names: the elder in Orthodoxy, the director or confessor in Catholicism, the pastor, mentor or spiritual friend among Protestants. The traditions say that no one is a good judge of their own case, that a guide offers perspective and accountability, and that the guide is a servant of the Spirit and the church, not a replacement for conscience or for God.

Key terms

Spiritual direction
Regular conversation with an experienced person who helps another notice God’s action in their life and respond to it.
Elder (geron, staretz)
In the Eastern tradition, a monk or priest with proven holiness and experience who guides others as a spiritual father or mother.
Confessor
A priest who hears confession and gives absolution. In Catholic and Orthodox practice, the confessor may also give spiritual counsel.
Cure of souls
The older name for pastoral care, the pastor’s responsibility for the spiritual welfare of those under his charge.
Seal of confession
The strict obligation of a priest never to reveal what is said in sacramental confession.
Accountability
A relationship in which a person gives another permission to ask about their conduct and to challenge them.
Spiritual friendship
A relationship between equals who help one another toward God. Aelred of Rievaulx wrote a medieval treatise on it.

Background

Scripture presents guidance as part of God’s design. Proverbs says that where there is no counsel the people fall, but in the multitude of counsellors there is safety (Proverbs 11:14). Paul tells the Galatians to restore a brother who is overtaken in a fault, in a spirit of meekness, and to bear one another’s burdens (Galatians 6:1-2). James tells the sick to call the elders and the faithful to confess their faults to one another and pray for one another (James 5:14-16). Hebrews tells believers to obey those who have rule over them and to submit, for they watch for souls (Hebrews 13:17).

In the desert the practice was central. A beginner would find an elder, open his thoughts and follow counsel. Cassian wrote that a monk should hide nothing from a senior, and that the devil rejoices when a thought is kept secret. Benedict makes the confession of evil thoughts to the abbot one of the steps of humility. The practice then spread, taking different forms in the East and West. Pope Gregory the Great wrote the Pastoral Rule, a guide for bishops on the care of souls that was influential for centuries.

Terminology varies. Some traditions use direction for an ongoing relationship distinct from confession. Others fold both into the pastor’s work. This lesson uses the common word guide and explains each tradition’s own terms.

Step-by-step explanation

Step 1: The elder in the East

In Orthodoxy, a spiritual father or mother is someone to whom a person goes for counsel and, ideally, with whom they develop a long relationship. The best known are the startsy, such as Seraphim of Sarov and the elders of Optina, whom thousands consulted. Many of the best guides were not priests. The role depends on holiness and experience, not on office, though the sacrament of confession is given by a priest.

Orthodox teachers add warnings. A true elder does not demand blind submission, and does not replace a person’s conscience. Ignatius Brianchaninov noted that in his day genuine elders were few, and advised people to read the Fathers and consult wise priests.

Step 2: The confessor and the director in the West

In Catholic practice, the sacrament of penance provides forgiveness through a priest, who is bound to absolute secrecy by the seal of confession. Alongside it, a tradition of spiritual direction developed. Ignatius of Loyola designed the Spiritual Exercises to be given with a guide. Teresa of Avila, John of the Cross and Francis de Sales all wrote for people they directed, and de Sales’s Introduction to the Devout Life, in 1609, addressed lay people. Directors need not be priests. Many are religious sisters or lay people trained in the work.

The Church teaches that direction is helpful and that a person is free to choose the guide. It also distinguishes direction from the sacrament, and from counseling, which treats psychological problems.

Step 3: The pastor in the Protestant traditions

The Reformers valued the pastor’s care of souls. Luther kept private confession and absolution as a practice though not as a required sacrament, and wrote of the mutual conversation and consolation of believers. Calvin’s Geneva had pastors visit families to give instruction. Richard Baxter, a seventeenth-century English Puritan, wrote The Reformed Pastor to urge ministers to catechize and counsel each parishioner personally. John Wesley organized his followers into classes and bands where members could confess faults and encourage one another. Dietrich Bonhoeffer, in Life Together, wrote that the Christian community needs the practice of confession to a brother.

In many Protestant churches today, direction has been restored under names such as mentoring, discipleship, spiritual friendship or pastoral counseling. Some Protestants worry that it can replace direct dependence on Christ, and the answer given is that a guide points to Christ and the Scriptures.

Step 4: What a good guide does

The traditions agree on several qualities. A guide listens before speaking, and knows Scripture and the tradition. A guide is humble and does not claim infallibility. A guide respects the freedom of the person and holds confidences. A guide has a life of prayer and a record of fruits. A guide knows the limits of their role and refers people to doctors, therapists or other help when needed.

Tests for a guide include the fruits in their own life, willingness to be accountable and absence of secrecy or pressure. The tradition says that the guide is a servant of the person’s relationship with God, not its owner.

Step 5: Misuse and boundaries

Abuse of this relationship is documented. Guides have exploited trust for control, money or sexual advantage, and some communities have discouraged members from seeking outside help. Warning signs include demands for secrecy, isolation from family and friends, pressure to hand over decisions, and claims of special revelation. Churches and religious orders have adopted codes of conduct and safeguarding rules in response. A person who has been harmed should seek help from competent authorities and trained professionals, and the tradition does not regard this as disloyalty.

  1. Who knows my spiritual life well enough to challenge me?
  2. What would I want to bring to a guide, and what would I hide?
  3. How would I test whether a guide is trustworthy?
  4. What is the difference between asking for advice and handing over my decisions?
  5. How do confession, counseling and direction differ in what they offer?
  6. What do I fear about opening my thoughts to someone?

Examples

Opening a thought

A young monk in Cassian’s account is troubled by persistent thoughts. His elder tells him that the matter loses power when it is spoken aloud and received without shock. The monk reports that his thoughts lessened, and Cassian presents this as the normal pattern. (An illustration of Cassian’s teaching.)

A Methodist band

In an early Methodist band, five or six people met weekly and each answered questions about the week: what temptations had they met and how had they responded. The meetings aimed at honesty and encouragement, not shame. (A description of the pattern, in outline.)

When to refer

A director notices that a woman who comes for guidance is describing symptoms of severe depression and thoughts of self-harm. The director encourages her to see her doctor the same day and helps her find a counselor, and continues to meet with her for prayer. (A constructed example.)

Different perspectives

Orthodox

Orthodox teaching values the spiritual father or mother as a guide whose authority comes from holiness and experience, and links this to the sacrament of confession. The tradition also warns against false elders and insists that the church, Scripture and the Fathers set the limits of any guide’s authority.

Catholic

The Catholic Church encourages spiritual direction as a help for all Christians, distinguishes it from the sacrament of penance and teaches that a person freely chooses a director. Several religious orders, including Jesuits, Carmelites and Benedictines, train directors, and many lay directors serve in parishes and retreat houses.

Protestant

Protestants hold that Christ is the one mediator and every believer has access to God, and also that the church is a community of mutual care. Lutheran and Anglican churches preserve forms of private confession. Many other churches use pastoral care, mentoring and small groups. Some evangelical writers have recovered the language of spiritual direction in recent decades.

Scholarly and professional view

Historians note that guidance relationships have a long history in many religions. Modern professional bodies for spiritual directors and chaplains set ethical standards, and mental health professionals advise that direction is not a substitute for therapy when a person has a clinical condition.

Why it matters

Many people who seek a deeper life of prayer try to do it alone. Nearly every tradition says this is risky, and the Sayings, Benedict, Ignatius and Wesley agree on the value of a trusted person. Knowing the roles, and also the signs of misuse, helps a student seek guidance wisely and be a better guide to others.

Common misunderstandings

Misunderstanding: Spiritual direction is a Catholic practice only.

Correction: Orthodox, Catholic and Protestant traditions all have forms of it. The vocabulary differs.

Misunderstanding: A spiritual director must be a priest or pastor.

Correction: In many traditions, lay people, religious sisters and brothers also serve. Priests are required only for sacramental confession and absolution.

Misunderstanding: A guide tells you what God wants you to do.

Correction: Good guides help a person notice and respond. They are not the voice of God and are not to make major decisions for another person.

Misunderstanding: Seeking help from a doctor or counselor shows lack of faith.

Correction: The traditions teach that the body and mind are part of the person, and that medical and psychological care are good gifts. Good guides refer when needed.

Knowledge check

How does spiritual direction differ from confession and counseling?

Confession, in sacramental traditions, is a rite of forgiveness given by a priest. Spiritual direction is an ongoing conversation about prayer and life with an experienced guide. Counseling treats psychological difficulties. They can overlap, but a good guide knows the differences and refers when needed.

What did Cassian and Benedict teach about opening one’s thoughts?

Cassian taught that a monk should hide nothing from an elder, because secrecy gives strength to temptation. Benedict made the confession of evil thoughts to the abbot a step of humility. The practice assumes that a person is a poor judge of their own case.

What did Wesley’s bands and Bonhoeffer’s writing add?

They show the Protestant forms of mutual confession and accountability. Wesley organized weekly bands in which members spoke honestly about temptations. Bonhoeffer, in Life Together, argued that a Christian community needs confession to a brother and the assurance of forgiveness.

What are warning signs of a harmful guide?

Demands for secrecy, isolation from family and friends, pressure to give up one’s decisions or money, claims of special revelation, and refusal of accountability. A person who has been harmed should seek help from competent authorities and trained professionals.

Think it through

  1. What qualities would you look for in a guide, and which are most important to you?
  2. How could you be a guide, in a modest way, for someone else?
  3. What would it cost you to be accountable to another person?

Independent assignment

Describing a good guide

In your notebook, write 350 to 500 words. Using the lesson and Scripture, write a profile of a trustworthy guide: what they do, what they do not do and how you would test them. Then write a paragraph on whom in your own life, if anyone, fills part of this role, and what step you could take to deepen it or find someone. Do not share this with anyone.

Further study